You have gracefully put into words a collection of ideas and conclusions that God has been waking me up to recently. I say “right on”, and won’t try to further the conversation by repeating what you’ve already said. I’m a songwriter, and though my SAT verbal score was abysmal (though the math and other analytical sections went splendidly), I still attempt to express truths in my stumbling way. My latest lyrics-in-progress mirror similar concerns – how many ‘Christian’ songs (including worship songs) sing to a ‘you’ who is never defined anywhere in the song.
———————————
What’s the problem with Christian music?
We don’t even mention the name of Christ anymore.
If you’re singing ’bout Jesus, prove it.
The Muslims are singing your song to a God with no son.

We’re singing “Bless your name”
But if it’s just the same,
We’d rather not say who we’re singing to,
We’re just a bit ashamed.

What’s the matter with Christian music?
We don’t even mention the name of Christ anymore.
The Christian “Top 40 Countdown” proves it.
A nameless “you” is all that we’re singing for.

Radios playing your song.
The Krishnas sing along.
They’re not affected, good or bad,
By your self-focused feelings-based ramblings.
————————
The reason this is a pet peeve of mine is because we live in a multi-religious culture now, and one can no longer assume that the listener of a song knows you’re singing about Jesus or the God of the Bible. Just visit Detroit – tour the Edsel Ford mansion, and you’ll find a Krishna temple. A few miles away in Hamtramck, they’re issuing the Muslim call to prayer.