Indoctrinating for Heaven or Hell


I once read about a pastor who was criticized for telling people he was baptizing that when they came up from the water not to be surprised if they were speaking in tongues—which was the case for many. Critics would argue that this set a false expectation.

But in thinking about this, I have to come down in favor of the pastor.

You see, each of us is receiving indoctrination. Just being alive means that a perpetual stream of thought patterns assaults us 24/7/365. Some of that stream is obvious; some is not.

Three responses to indoctrination exist: We can embrace an idea, ignore it, or counter it.

When we look at the American Church today, we have to ask just what kind of indoctrination we are receiving. By and large, the message coming out of our churches sounds like this:

Jesus loves you, even though you sometimes sin. You can rest in His grace and not be worried about doing things for Him except to read your Bible and pray. Show up on Sundays and to the occasional church event. If you are young, go to a good college and get a degree that ensures a solid job working for a reputable company. Find a good-looking Christian mate from among the right kind of people, buy a house, and have 2.2 kids. Make sure those kids are loaded with activities and skills so they can get into an even better, more expensive college. Live in the right neighborhood with the right kind of people who can help you advance in life and build your career. Go on vacations and enjoy yourself. Give some money every once in a while to worthy causes. And most of all, be happy with your Christian experience, even if you sometimes wonder whether it’s really all it’s cut out to be.

Seriously, isn’t that the indoctrination most of us Christians receive from childhood until the day we die?

In stark contrast, here is the Bible’s true indoctrination:

You have been crucified with Christ. Any pretense you had to living like worldly people is dead. Jesus Christ, the Lord of All, dwells inside you. Greater is He that is in you than he that is in the world. You are being changed from one degree of glory to another, moving from sinner to saint. You are seated in the heavenlies with Christ and are empowered by His Spirit. Therefore, nothing is impossible for you. The Christian life is filled with miracles; they should be expected. You overcome the world because Christ did. Take dominion. Make disciples of all nations and tear down strongholds. Worship Christ with your entire being, even if that puts you at odds with the establishment. Pray at all times and in all places, and expect those prayers to come to great fruition.

You will be hated for Jesus’ sake. Because you have counted all things lost for the sake of knowing Christ, you will live a countercultural life that will be misunderstood by most people. For this reason, many of you will be martyred for the Gospel because Christ is in you, is transforming you, and compels you to speak about Him.

Your love will be for all men, no matter race, creed, or color. You will care for the downtrodden and weak. You will repay good for evil and will love and pray for those who persecute you. Your life is now hidden with Christ, therefore, you are not your own. You only do what the Father is doing, not what you want. Your life is expendable for the cause of Christ. Therefore, you should not think too highly of yourself, but in humility you should value others as much as yourself and your family, if God in his graciousness gives you a family. Your primary family is the family of God, and building up the community of faith through the supernatural gifts God has implanted in you is one of your primary reasons for existence. Meet with the community of faith as much as possible and ensure that no one among you lacks for anything needful, even if that means you personally do without the trappings of worldly class and culture. And no matter what kind of life you end up living, you should give thanks to God at all times.

Most of all, never stop laying ahold of Christ and abiding in Him.

We don’t set that kind of expectation in our churches, though, do we?

The Church in America bears little to no resemblance to the Church of the 1st century because our indoctrination is lukewarm or nonexistent. Period. 'The Christian Martyrs' Last Prayer' by Jean-Léon GérômeSome may argue that they do try to indoctrinate people into that more Biblical model. But the fact is that we hear it rarely, and surely not enough to compete with the nonstop message the world gives. And a worldly message abhors a vacuum, too.

As a Church, we have got to get serious about speaking truth to each other. We have got to stop watering down our indoctrination. If we don’t, the world is all set to step in and give us its own deviant set of expectations.

In closing, imagine what the next generation of Christians would be like if we set just the one expectation that they would be martyred for Christ because they love Jesus so much. Too strong? I don’t think so. For too long we’ve been preaching a watered down message that asks nothing. Why then should we be surprised at the powerless outcome?

5 thoughts on “Indoctrinating for Heaven or Hell

  1. Peyton


    Excellent post, Dan! Reminds me of the old hymn parody:

    Sit down, O men of God
    His kingdom He will bring,
    Whenever it may please His will
    You need not do a thing.


    P.S., I know that the original said “cannot do a thing”, but this is the more liberal version that I learned at my father’s knee.

  2. hmm…is Facebook going to kill the blogs? Comments here are dwindling from years past and I’m betting that folks are ‘commenting’ on facebook (or twitter). I rather enjoyed the blog comments that stayed put so I could read back over them, you could respond to each…have a ‘conversation’ in slow time.

    I see you post on Facebook, a couple of comments maybe and then you scroll off the page…another blow to ‘community’ however ephemeral that is online.

    Just being curmudgeonly.. you are right on as usual. Please keep making us look at ourselves.

  3. The painting you have there of the martyrs in the collosseum is fairly well known if a little historically inaccurate—although at the moment I don’t recollect the name of the artist. But there is an even better and more startling painting by a polish painter named Henryk Siemiradzki which is titled (in English) “Nero’s Torches“.

    Siemiradzki’s vivid painting is referencing a very brief remark in Tacitus about Nero using xtians as a cheap form of lighting during some evening festivities. Study this painting in full size and look at the expressions on people’s faces, and deduce their various attitudes. Also, keep in mind that as far as the Romans were concerned the xtians up on the poles are getting their just deserts for being criminal arsonists and for causing the recent, devasting fire in Rome. Remember, most of them really thought the xtians were guilty, and that some brutal Roman retribution was called for. The inscription in the accusations attached on the poles, if you look carefully, read something in Latin like “christianvs incendiator vrbis”.

    On a different note, what is funny nowdays is reading the Wikipedia on the subject of the persecutions of the xtians under S.P.Q.R. Apparently, there has been a recent revisionist trend among historians that says, in so many words, that the persecutions were comparatively minor in extend and in the number of casualties—in other words, those dang xtians were exaggerating how bad it was.

  4. James t kirk

    A ballsy and well timed post.

    One of the few Christian blog posts I’ve read recently that got me fired up!

    Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *