The Best of Cerulean Sanctum 2005

Standard

Cerulean Sanctum logo2005 has been a year of tremendous growth at Cerulean Sanctum. Hundreds of readers left comments and blessed me by what they wrote. Most of the posts linked here were cited as being particularly helpful (or contentious) by the folks who stop by here on a regular basis, so I hope this collection of the best of this blog will provide plenty of reading material for anyone looking for challenging ideas that seek to reflect the heart of the Lord.

God bless you all in 2006 and beyond!

General Church Issues

I ended 2005 with a series covering damaging messages that worm their way into the Gospel presentation in American Christianity.

The Little Things series looked at issues within the Church that often go ignored, but which can contribute to hurting others, failing in our ministry, and sabotaging the mission of the Church.

On the Brink of a Quantum Singularity with Calvin and Arminius asks if the Church is better served by staying at the feet of Christ rather than exploring the fringes of what it means to be in Him.

That Nutty Small Group Dialectic discusses Hegel’s “thesis + antithesis = synthesis” ideal and how it can wreck small group Bible studies.

The Reason the Church Exists explores the mission of the Church.

Ford, GM, and the Church and More Signs We Are Not Ready ask whether the Church in America is ready to go through difficult times, and if not, why not?

Is Christianity Broken? and its follow-up, Recovering Christianity’s Balance, look at the plethora of beliefs within Christian thought today, searching for a holy middle ground that best fits the narrow way.

A Long Obedience in the Same Direction seeks to restore a rational view of long-term Christian discipleship when we confront folks who are making mistakes in their walk with Christ.

Lifestyle Issues and Christian Living

The Christian & the Business World series garnered much attention throughout the blogosphere, providing an in-depth analysis of how the Church in America underestimated the power of the Industrial Revolution to profoundly change not only our society, but the Church itself—neither for the better. In the end, I called for a radical rethinking of how we live as countercultural Christians in a world altered by business practices rooted in Darwinian survival of the fittest morality.

Are You a Hamster? Sometimes it feels like we’re on a spinning wheel with no way to get off. But a countercultural Christian solution exists.

The American Church’s Five Most Pressing Needs—the title says it all.

Love Sin / Hate Sin
—What do we do when we say we hate sin—but not really?

What the Church Is Not Learning explores the lessons the Church in America resists.

The Humble Warrior
demolishes the faux-manliness trumpeted in bestselling men’s books.

The To-Do List Christian is a peculiar creature that is half human, half PDA, and not entirely alive.

Stay-at-Home Dads (or “Guys the Church Would Like to Forget Exist”)
As one of those men, I ask why so many Christians are willing to point fingers at us, but offer no solutions to the broken system that made us.

Singleness: Radical Answers for a Harsh Reality goes deep into the abandonment of many singles by their churches and the Christian culture we’ve erected in the early 21st century.

The Problem of Porn
examines the underlying causes and issues that afflict those trapped in pornography.

Another Look at the Church’s Missing Men is a follow-up to a post last year, with an explanation as to why men are dropping out of our churches.

Trying to Get By
sees the lost as sheep without a shepherd.

Isolationism, Materialism, and the Evils of Our Age blasts the accommodations we have made to our culture, but which the Church may unwittingly support because it has sought no better way.

Tougher People looks at the wimpiness of the West.

A Hodgepodge of Thoughts on This July Fourth offers some thoughts on cultural accommodation.

Controversial Subjects

The Myths of Homeschooling Series examined the hype that often surrounds the homeschooling movement, seeking common sense and true Christian charity from all sides of the discussion.

Creating a Theology from Unbelief was perhaps the most contentious post this year as I asked if we truly believe the Bible the way we claim to.

The Truth About Women (and Men)
posits that we Christians have done a terrible job raising young women (and men) for the Lord.

Christian Blogging: A Waste of Time?
Well, ask a bunch of bloggers if they’re wasting their time blogging and you’re sure to stir up a hornet’s nest.

Psychology a Pseudo-Science?
asks the hard question of psychology as it further penetrates Christian thought.

Not So Wild About Harry
—bring up Harry Potter and not get varying opinions? Hah!

Charismatic Issues

The last quarter of 2005 found the Godblogosphere choosing sides over cessationist and charismatic (or as it has been called recently, “continualist”) positions. As a non-charismaniac charismatic, I took up the cause that God still works supernaturally, not only by His own action, but through us, His human agents. In addition, a couple posts addressed the low position afforded the Holy Spirit in many of our churches.

Advertising Ashes and Overflowing both ask if the Church is honoring the third Person of the Trinity in faith and practice.

The Least-Believed Verse in the Bible
wonders why so few believe that the mountain can be cast into the sea if we only have faith.

God Is Still Speaking
counters a post by Steve Camp claiming that He is not.

Response to “Some Say It Blundered” reverses the burden of proof on charismatics to prove that the gifts still exist today.

How Not to Be a Charismatic Headcase is a companion post to 2003’s Charismatic Churches and the Cult of New asking charismatics to ditch the charismania.

Heretic Hunting and Judgment

Each of the posts listed here sought some sanity in the ongoing battle of who’s right and who’s wrong in American Christianity. So many times we try to justify our own positions while ignoring our own foibles. There have been several pitched battles between bloggers and church movements that amounted to nothing more than namecalling and ugliness. Let’s hope 2006 is a finer year for all of us.

Let’s Play “Spot the Heretic!” Soon everyone will be a heretic.

Witch Hunt
questions our willingness to so easily find fault in other Christians.

Arrogance, Ignorance, and “I Don’t Know” wonders why so few are willing to say “I don’t know.”

Nyah, Nyah, Nyah, We’re Not Listening!
asks why the traditional church and emerging church are so unwilling to listen to each other’s criticisms while also examining their own faults.

On Consigning Enemies of Christ to Hell asks why it is so easy to condemn others, but so hard to help them grow in Christ.

Tearing Down the Gallows calls for a greater willingness to correct others in true Christian love.

Has the Christian Blogosphere Lost Its Collective Mind? questions the Christian blogosphere’s cannibalistic practice of consuming its own in a fit of pique.

A Long Obedience in the Same Direction is a cautionary tale of judging God’s timetable in working out His perfect will in other believers’ lives.

Evil

Curses are real and can hamstring Christians if we fail to understand them.

The Chthonic Unmentionable delves into the world of the demonic and asks why so many Evangelicals start whistling in the air when confronted with the work of fallen angels.

Writing and Publishing

I work as a freelance writer, plus I’m finishing up my first novel. These two posts received plenty of commentary from other Christian writers.

Rock { Christian Author } Hard Place discusses the fine line a Christian novelist must walk in order to be all things to all Christians.

The Desperate Need for Heroes examines the trend in Christian fiction toward fitting heroes with progressively larger feet of clay.

More Cowbell Awards

The More Cowbell Award—the award no one wants to win—is a tongue-in-cheek look at the lunatic fringe of American Christianity.

Announcing the “More Cowbell Award” at Cerulean Sanctum explains the whole silly concept.

The More Cowbell Award I wonders how the Church Growth Movement managed to lose the Gospel along with all that church growth stuff.

The More Cowbell Award II has the courage to ask why producers of Christian music feel the need to back up adult singers with kiddie choirs.

The More Cowbell Award III delves into the seamy underbelly of Christian adware. Say no to fish stickers!

Hidden Messages of American Christianity Wrap-up

Standard

MegaphoneThis series has proven to be popular and some have suggested it’s too early to be concluding it. No doubt there are dozens of hidden messages we Christians send along with the Gospel, confusing its purity, especially in the ears of the lost. Stepping back and analyzing what we say and how we say it should be an essential part of all we do. We live in an age when truth is lacking or is filled with so much noise as to be obscured altogether, so diligence in keeping the Gospel free from extraneous garbage has never been more needed.

A commenter wondered why I did not talk about the mixing of the Gospel with political messages. That’s a good one that I should have discussed, so I’ll give it a few words. Personally, I believe that neither of the two major parties in the United States is pursuing righteousness in governance. Aside from one or two important hot-button issues, both the Democrat and Republican parties are so highly compromised on truth that Christians should avoid the rah-rah tendencies we might have to wholeheartedly advocate either. This is not a call to drop out of the proper role each citizen has to utilize the freedoms this country affords, but to always vote soberly and with the understanding that political entities will, by nature, always be compromised. Blending the pulpit with politics will always degrade the Gospel message. Ultimately, the Christian’s allegiance is not to kingdoms of this world. When we forget that, we go off-message.

It was suggested that something be said about denominationalism, while another commenter noted that most denominations operate by emphasizing one aspect of the Gospel over another. I believe that is largely true from my own experience. Balance is needed at all times lest the Church of Jesus Christ operate more like the seven blind men examining the elephant. Each man thought his description of the mysterious beast most apt, but each fell short of understanding. It is a sad truth that the Church in America lurches from emphasis to emphasis, but I don’t have any answer for this other than to speak to individual Christians and exhort them to consider what all the major Christian voices are saying and try to find the middle ground without compromising on truth. Christianity, while it does make exclusive truth claims, walks a narrow road between extremes of practice and belief. We Christians today need to stay doctrinally pure, but also understand the competing ideals within different denominations that might exist to make us more fully rounded in the Lord.

I think I need to move on to other things, though, so in ending this series I have only one further comment.

Of all the hidden messages of American Christianity, none is more hidden than you and me. While it is a cliché to say that you and I might be the only Jesus that some will ever see, it’s a good cliché to remember. What we are, no matter how young or old in the Lord we might be, reflects out to the dying world. Of all the hidden messages then, none is more important than how each of us personally reflects Christ and His Gospel. Understanding where we need to improve in our own transmission of the pure message is critical. What noise does each of us transmit that shouts out over the Gospel message, obscuring it? Does our self-righteous cause others to turn away from the Lord? Does our lack of knowledge of the Scriptures make it seem that we’re not all that interested in knowing what we supposedly believe, even as we try to tell others that they should believe as we do? Does our forgetting our neighbor in his time of need speak more words to him than our attempts to share the Lord? What are our own lacks that blur truth with lies?

In the end, the hidden messages of American Christianity start and end with the way we live out the Gospel before the dying world. That calls for us to soberly consider where each of us has compromised the message by the ways in which we live. That will look different for each of us, but no matter the case, God is greater if we only let Him be:

The word that came to Jeremiah from the LORD: “Arise, and go down to the potter’s house, and there I will let you hear my words.” So I went down to the potter’s house, and there he was working at his wheel. And the vessel he was making of clay was spoiled in the potter’s hand, and he reworked it into another vessel, as it seemed good to the potter to do.
—Jeremiah 18:1-4 ESV

The series posts:

1. Hidden Messages of American Christianity: Classism

2. Hidden Messages of American Christianity: Kneeling at the Altar of Excellence

3. Hidden Messages of American Christianity: Correctness Before Love

4. Hidden Messages of American Christianity: Pastor O’Gill and the Little People

5. Hidden Messages of American Christianity: “We’re Cool, Too!”

6. Hidden Messages of American Christianity: “Family Cocooning Session: No Trespassing Allowed!”

7. Hidden Messages of American Christianity: The Outstretched Hand

Hidden Messages of American Christianity: The Outstretched Hand

Standard

This is the seventh (and last) in a series of posts covering the hidden messages that sneak into American churches' proclamation of the Gospel. For more background, please refer to this post.

Though today's post addresses what is a hidden message, I don't have any answers for it. I'm throwing it out there because I hear it all the time. I'm hoping that you readers have more insights than I do. (I'm also going to ask readers to bear with me because I sense this post is going to ramble excessively.)

It's one of the most prevalent excuses I encounter in my area of the country for people not attending church. Men who avoid church like the plague cite it more than any other issue for their lack of attendance, Offering platefrom what I've personally heard. The older the commenter gets, the more likely this issue sticks in his craw.

It's money.

No, I'm not talking about folks who are ticked off that the church is preaching budgeting instead of preaching Christ, it's their complaining about the church asking for money. It's as if no other message can get through once the offering plate is passed. The "There they go again shilling for money!" lament is raised and the sermon message is now permitted to go in one ear and out the other.

"Always with the money thing! Why do they need so much money, Martha? The pastor makes twice what I do and I caught a whiff of Chanel No. 5 on his wife when I walked past. How much does that stuff cost? A thousand dollars an ounce? And he's asking for money? How low can you get?"

Now I'm not naive enough to think that the majority of these grumblers aren't using money as an excuse to sleep in on Sunday or to justify their rejection of Christ. But why do I hear this complaint so often if it didn't carry some actual weight?

At one point in my life I attended a well-known Presbyterian church in the toniest suburb in Pittsburgh. The corporate elite of Pittsburgh occupied the pews every Sunday. It had a chauffeur's entrance. The choir (paid) consisted of the leads of the city opera. When industrial meltdowns and financial strife rocked the area in the mid-Eighties, this church was targeted by activists and their Sunday services disrupted for no other reason than wealth. The church I left last year was suburban, middle to upper-class, and rarely asked for money. The pastor had a hard time bringing up the issue. As a result, this huge church was always encountering one cash flow problem after another. My present church is more rural ("penturbian," if you want the exact, trendy word), is lower to middle-class, has a mini-sermon about tithing shared by one of the elders every Sunday, and seems to do a reputable job staying in the black. Not only that, but every time there is a need over and above the regular giving, people always come through with an amount that surprises me.

I'd love to draw some kind of conclusion about these three churches, but there are too many variables. One never asked for money because it was loaded. One rarely asked for money, should have had it in abundance anyway, but didn't. One talks about money every Sunday, doesn't seem to want for it, plus it always has reserves. No matter the case, money plays into every aspect of how each of those three churches operate. That's true with every church, every ministry. But is there a way to downplay the whole issue of money so that those who complain that churches are only out for money have no more ammo for their assault?

It's Christmastime, so we're now under bombardment by Project Angeltree, Chuck Colson's organization. We donated money to them a few years ago to send the kids of prisoners to summer camp. Christian camping being near and dear to my heart, I couldn't say no when my wife suggested it, even though it violated our decision to only give to charities run by people we personally knew. Starting in September, I swear we get letters from Angeltree every week, plus scores of e-mails.

I'm not the type to complain that Christians are always asking for money, but the sheer volume of mail we get from Angeltree makes me uncomfortable. Whatever we gave a few years ago has been more than eaten up from the cost of their mailings to us.

So I can understand how some people have a problem with Christians asking for money. This isn't to say that money is not needed, but the sheer amount of money that some churches and ministries burn through is incredible. To sustain whatever they're doing, more and more money is solicited. But is this hidden message that churches and parachurch organizations are always on the lookout for cash really a message we want to send, even if it is not entirely true in every situation?

Now I can't speak for parachurch organizations, but I wonder if the way we do church today relies too much on money. I think our buildings are too expensive, not only to build, but to maintain. I don't see in Acts that the early Church spent their money on buildings. Nor was there much in the way of expensive programs and church initiatives. Benevolences were turned around and filtered back to the neediest in the community of believers in the early Church, yet the way we collect church monies today often leaves the givers in the dark as to where their money went. And too often, overhead consumes the majority of money rather than benevolences. Shouldn't we be asking if we're handling money for the Kingdom in the best way possible?

Shouldn't that advise the way our churches are structured and operated? What if a church met in homes rather than an expensive church building? What if the pastoral staff went unpaid (or partially compensated), but was large enough so that one person didn't carry the whole ministry load, each staff member living the life of a genuine "tentmaker"? What if we went beyond tithing and set everything we caretake for the Lord on the table so that anything needed was available to anyone at any time for his or her need? What if the Church functioned to unite giver and receiver personally, rather than having our monies go into an ethereal pool of funds? What if our newfound financial reliance on each other allowed us to step out of the rat race? What if churches didn't ask for money at all?

Most of all, what if the Church handled money so uniquely that it took away any objections by those who believe that Christianity is all about the Benjamins?

I know that Americans are funny about money, but I still hold out hope that one day our churches will look different because we've found a better way to handle it. The house churches in China are destitute compared with the Communist-approved state churches, but somehow they keep growing, effectively making disciples in a way we in America long ago forgot. While there are many mitigating factors in that growth in Chinese house churches, I've got to believe that our attitudes toward money in the American Church are partly to blame for our lack of effectiveness. We've built some fancy churches and installed some expensive programming, but what do we have to show for it?

Is it possible that something better could arise in the American Church if all our money disappeared some day? Maybe if it did, the lost might be able to look beyond the our hidden message of money and to the true heart of the Gospel.